| 1958 |
Anna Badame |
1959 |
Diane Everly |
| 1960 |
Diane Hull |
1961 |
Linda Harbick |
| 1962 |
Pam James |
1963 |
Barbara Richartz (Campanella) |
| 1964 |
Jean Richartz (Longmire) |
1965 |
Donna Steinmetz |
| 1966 |
Andrea Davis (Rambo) |
1967 |
Kathy Prickett |
| 1968 |
Barbara Bierce |
1969 |
Joan Williamson |
| 1970 |
Sue Mathis |
1971 |
Christine Hartman |
| 1972 |
Cara Simons |
1973 |
Geri Mansi Johnson |
| 1974 |
Liz McDonald |
1975 |
Robin Lee |
| 1976 |
Julie Zelesnick |
1977 |
Denise Hurd Law |
| 1978 |
Kathy McCusker (Zale) |
1979 |
Cyndee Ragone |
| 1980 |
Denise Higbee (Faust) |
1981 |
Patti Burns |
| 1982 |
Kelly Hopkins |
1983 |
Barbara Jean Campanella |
| 1984 |
Michele Roi |
1985 |
Jeanine Warrington |
| 1986 |
Debora Stens |
1987 |
Dory Hohenberger Valeriano |
| 1988 |
Lorraine Swallow Shields |
1989 |
Kristie Vogel |
| 1990 |
Margaret Zeoli |
1991 |
Rosemary Andacie-Martin |
| 1992 |
Maureen Fitzgerald |
1993 |
Karen Cunningham Mitchell |
| 1994 |
Nicole Forsyth |
1995 |
Kristin Clement |
| 1996 |
Nichole Starinieri Bianco |
1997 |
Kristen McKenna |
| 1998 |
Lauren Ciccarelli |
1999 |
Kristen Miller |
| 2000 |
Serena Rebecca |
2001 |
Alexis Torres |
| 2002 |
Lauren Boswell |
2003 |
Sara Baxter |
| 2004 |
Brianna Jeanne Campanella |
2005 |
Jill Doyle |
| 2006 |
Christina Mottola |
2007 |
Madelynn Scott |
| 2008 |
Lindsay Kellum |
2009 |
Kalyn Meyers |
| 2010 |
Noelle Cinquino |
2011 |
Karley Hall |